Best LED GU10 lights – the winner is flourescent (no, now its LED)

Our kitchen has 20 GU10 downlight fittings, with 35W bulbs in.  So, 700W, costing about 7p/hour to run (and of course all the carbon emissions that go with it) – and fairly frequently one of the bulbs fails.  With LED GU10 bulbs now well established, for the last couple of years (on and off) I have been trying to find some LED bulbs that we liked.  We have tried the standard 17 LED bulbs, in ‘normal and warm white (1,5,6 below) but they just weren’t bright enough.  We also had two sorts that blew in a few tens of hours which is far worse than halogen bulbs.  We have tried a more powerful 35 LED bulb (No 2 below) … which was brighter, but too blue white, and poured all the light into a tiny spot on the dark granite below it leaving the room feeling dark.  We have tried two sorts of 3W bulbs (3 and 4 below) which were MUCH more expensive, at almost £20 each, but the first was too white and too directional, and the second was a better colour, but annoyingly simply wouldn’t fit in the fittings (watch for this – loads of options are too deep for some sorts of GU10 fittings).  And for both, they simply weren’t quite bright enough.

IMG_5996.JPG

But, we have now found a winner, and it is … a compact fluorescent bulb.  It is exactly GU10 size, so fits the fittings well; it comes in warm white which is the colour we wanted; it is 7W, so as bright as our 35W originals but costs less than 2p an hour to run; it gets bright reasonably fast – all fluorescents take some minutes, but this really isn’t that noticeable – it’s actually quite nice on a dark morning!; and, the light spreads widely, so evenly lighting the room, with plenty hitting the walls to make it feel brighter.  We got them from http://www.energybulbs.co.uk (see here), and they cost us just £5.55 each.

So, whilst the future might be LED or similar, after some considerable effort, the best answer we found today is a CFL.

EDIT, 27/3/11 – Since I wrote this I have found that Surface mount LED GU10 bulbs are the best … and CFLs are total rubbish if it is cold.  See this post.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Best LED GU10 lights – the winner is flourescent (no, now its LED)

  1. Tim says:

    Given you have 20 I assume the downlights are your only source of kitchen lighting?

    I am in the early stages of having a kitchen designed and was thinking downlights. However I wondered whether you found that they cast a heavy shadow and whether this is annoying for food preparation?

    • Greg says:

      It isn’t quite the only lighting, but it’s all we tend to use. And, the answer is no, it’s been fine – but the room is 4m by 4m, so there is plenty of diagonal beams coming in. In fact this is now better with the CFLs as the beam angle is wider. I would say that we are still getting used to the slow start on CFls though – when first turned on they are pretty dim, though it doesn’t take them long to get to full brightness (this was why we started with LED, but post explains why that wasn’t the success we hoped.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s